Syndication BreakdownStart here

The Distribution WaterfallNil Masferrer Jiménez

Distributable Cash: What Is Left After Reserves, Fees and Debt

Every waterfall starts with an input that nobody draws. The definition of distributable cash decides how much reaches the first tier, and it is written by the party that decides the reserves.

Descriptions of the distribution waterfall start with money arriving at the top tier. They rarely say where that money comes from, or how much of the property's income was taken out before it arrived.

The input has a name in the operating agreement. It might be "Distributable Cash," "Net Cash Flow" or "Cash Available for Distribution." Whatever the label, it is a definition, and the definition does as much to decide your return as any tier below it.

The chain from rent to distribution

The subtraction runs in roughly the same order in most agreements. Each step is a line you can find in the documents.

  1. Gross collected revenue. Rent and other income actually collected, not rent billed.
  2. Less operating expenses, which gives net operating income.
  3. Less debt service, meaning interest and any scheduled principal on the mortgage.
  4. Less capital expenditures paid from operations rather than from the renovation budget raised at closing.
  5. Less lender-required reserve deposits. Agency lenders, for example, generally require a replacement reserve for capital items, funded monthly under the loan documents.
  6. Less partnership-level costs: tax preparation, audit, insurance for the entity, and fees paid to the sponsor ahead of investors.
  7. Less any further reserves the manager decides to hold.

What is left enters the first tier. Everything in steps 3 to 7 is money your projected return figure may have included and the waterfall never sees.

The two lines with discretion in them

Most of the chain is arithmetic. Two items are judgment, and both are exercised by the manager.

Discretionary reserves. A typical definition ends by subtracting "such reserves as the Manager determines, in its reasonable discretion, to be appropriate." Holding more cash can be prudent, and reserves can also be built quietly ahead of a problem the manager has not yet reported. The clause lets the manager do either without asking anyone. When distributions are suspended, this is usually the clause being used.

Fee priority. If the asset management fee is a partnership expense, it is paid before distributable cash exists, in good years and bad. If it is subordinated to the preferred return, the sponsor collects it only after investors receive their preferred amount for the period. The same fee, placed one line lower, moves the risk of a weak year from you to the sponsor.

A worked comparison

Neither presentation is false. They answer different questions, and only one of them is the number the waterfall uses. A projection that quotes cash-on-cash returns on cash flow after debt service is measuring step 3, and your distributions are determined at step 7. The gap between the two is a fair question for any pro forma.

Operating cash and capital proceeds are different pools

Most agreements define two inputs, not one. Distributable cash from operations comes out of the chain above. Proceeds from a sale or refinance are a separate defined term, often with their own waterfall and their own order of tiers.

The distinction matters because the tiers are not always the same. Operating cash may go through a preferred-return tier only, while capital proceeds go first to return of capital. How the two pools interact, and why a refinance can change your return profile without a sale, is covered in refinance and capital event distributions.

Taxable income does not follow the cash

One more consequence of the definition. Your Schedule K-1 reports your share of the partnership's income, deductions and credits under its allocation provisions. It does not report distributable cash. The partnership's taxable income is computed under the tax rules, and cash held in reserve can still count as income on it.

In most syndications depreciation reduces taxable income well below the cash distributed, so the issue stays theoretical. It becomes real in a year with large reserves and little depreciation left, when you can owe tax on income you did not receive.

What to look for in the documents

The waterfall decides how the money is split. The definition decides how much money there is to split, and the operating agreement usually hands that decision to the manager.

Primary sources

Every factual claim above is traceable to a filing, a rule or an agency publication. These are the ones this article relies on.

  1. Fannie Mae Multifamily Guide, replacement reserve requirementsmfguide.fanniemae.com
  2. IRS, Partner's Instructions for Schedule K-1 (Form 1065)irs.gov
  3. 26 U.S.C. 704, partner's distributive sharelaw.cornell.edu
  4. Investor.gov, private placements explainedinvestor.gov

Questions readers ask

What is distributable cash in a syndication?

The amount of cash the operating agreement treats as available to go through the distribution waterfall in a period. It is usually what remains of the property's income after operating expenses, debt service, capital spending, reserve deposits and partnership-level costs, including any fees paid ahead of investors.

Is distributable cash the same as net operating income?

No. Net operating income is measured before debt service, capital spending and reserves. Distributable cash is measured after them, and can be a small fraction of NOI in a leveraged deal.

Who decides how much goes into reserves?

Lender-required reserves are fixed by the loan documents. Any reserve above that is normally set by the manager under a discretion clause in the operating agreement, which limited partners rarely have the power to override.

Does the asset management fee come out before my distributions?

It depends on the agreement. In many deals it is a partnership expense paid before distributable cash is calculated. Some agreements subordinate all or part of it to the preferred return, which changes who absorbs a shortfall.

Why do I owe tax on income I did not receive?

Because a partner is taxed on their share of the partnership's income, not on the cash distributed. Cash kept in reserves can still produce taxable income on your Schedule K-1.

Read next

This article sits in section II, The Distribution Waterfall, which runs to 12 articles in reading order.