UBTI and UDFI Inside a Self-Directed IRA
The account is the investor, not you. It has its own rules, its own possible tax liability, and its own filing obligation, and the custodian will not work any of it out for you.
An individual retirement account is tax-exempt, which is the point of it. That exemption is not unlimited, and a leveraged real estate syndication is one of the clearest cases where it stops applying.
Nothing here is tax advice. This is a description of a mechanism that is regularly discovered after the fact.
Two acronyms¶
UBTI — unrelated business taxable income. Income earned by a tax-exempt account from a trade or business unrelated to its exempt purpose. Rents from real property are generally excluded from it.
UDFI — unrelated debt-financed income. Section 514 removes that exclusion to the extent income is attributable to debt-financed property. The debt-financed portion is treated as unrelated business taxable income even though rent would otherwise be excluded.
Since virtually every real estate syndication uses a mortgage, the second concept is the one that reaches most retirement account investors.
How the proportion is determined¶
The computation is set out in section 514 and is done by the partnership and reported to the partner. In broad terms, the taxable share is determined by reference to the ratio of average acquisition indebtedness to the average adjusted basis of the property.
The practical implication follows directly: the more leveraged the property, the greater the share of income that falls outside the exclusion. A deal financed at a substantial loan-to-value ratio can pass a substantial proportion of its income through as debt-financed.
That last point is the one worth carrying away. In the early years, depreciation frequently reduces debt-financed income to nothing. At disposition, gain arrives without that shelter, and the account can face its largest exposure in its final year in the deal.
The filing obligation¶
Where the account has gross unrelated business taxable income above the threshold set by the IRS, a Form 990-T is required. The account files, the tax is paid from the account's own assets, and the return is filed through or with the custodian.
Two practical points that cause trouble:
The custodian may not prepare it. Policies differ. Some custodians prepare Form 990-T for an additional fee; others notify the account holder that a filing appears to be required and leave arrangements to them. Establish which before investing, not in the spring.
Paying the tax from outside the account is not an option. Contributing money to cover the account's tax bill is itself a contribution, subject to the ordinary contribution limits and rules. The account must have liquidity, which a fully invested account holding an illiquid syndication interest may not.
Prohibited transactions, briefly¶
Separate from the tax question and at least as serious. Retirement accounts are subject to rules prohibiting transactions with disqualified persons, a category that includes the account holder, certain family members, and entities they control.
Investing an account into a deal sponsored by yourself or by a disqualified person, personally guaranteeing debt of an entity the account invests in, or providing services to the investment can create serious consequences for the account's status.
That is a genuinely technical area with severe outcomes and it belongs with an adviser who specializes in it, before the transaction rather than after.
Where the reporting comes from¶
The partnership calculates the debt-financed portion and reports it to the partner, generally in the box 20 codes on the Schedule K-1 and in the attached statements.
Two things follow. The information has to be provided — a sponsor whose K-1 omits the relevant codes has left the account unable to compute its own position — and it arrives on the same timetable as everything else, which is frequently after the individual filing deadline.
Asking a sponsor whether they report these figures, and whether they have done so for the last two years, is a specific question with a specific answer, and it is worth asking before an account subscribes rather than in the spring afterwards.
Before an account subscribes¶
All of it is answerable in advance. None of it is answerable by this site for your situation: a retirement account investing in a leveraged partnership is exactly the case for professional advice, obtained before the subscription documents are signed.
Primary sources
Every factual claim above is traceable to a filing, a rule or an agency publication. These are the ones this article relies on.
- IRS, unrelated business income taxirs.gov
- IRS, About Form 990-T, Exempt Organization Business Income Tax Returnirs.gov
- Legal Information Institute, 26 US Code 514 on unrelated debt-financed incomelaw.cornell.edu
- IRS, retirement plans FAQs regarding IRAsirs.gov
- IRS, Partner's Instructions for Schedule K-1 (Form 1065)irs.gov
Questions readers ask
Can a retirement account owe tax on a syndication investment?
Yes. Unrelated business taxable income and, in particular, unrelated debt-financed income can be taxable to the account itself, and the account may have to file a Form 990-T.
Why does leverage cause this?
Rental income is generally excluded from unrelated business taxable income, but section 514 removes the exclusion to the extent income is attributable to debt-financed property. Syndications are leveraged, so a portion of the income falls outside the exclusion.
How much of the income is affected?
It is computed by reference to the ratio of average acquisition indebtedness to the property's average adjusted basis. With substantial leverage, a substantial share of the income can be affected.
Does this mean a syndication is a bad IRA investment?
This site does not make that judgment, and the answer depends on facts specific to the account and the deal. What matters is knowing the exposure exists before investing, because it is frequently discovered afterwards.
Who files the Form 990-T?
The account files, generally through the custodian, and the tax is paid from the account's own assets. The custodian may prepare it or may require you to arrange preparation; policies differ.
Read next
- TaxThe Schedule K-1 a Syndication Sends You, Box by BoxThe form reports your allocated share of the partnership's income, deductions and capital. It will not match the cash you received, and it is not supposed to.
- TaxDepreciation, Cost Segregation and Bonus DepreciationA deduction requiring no cash outlay, accelerated into the early years. It changes the timing of deductions, not the total, and it enlarges recapture at sale.
- TaxPassive Activity Loss Rules: Why Your Losses May Be SuspendedThe rule that decides whether a syndication's first-year paper loss reduces your tax bill. For most W-2 investors, the answer is not this year.